Tim Cook, Dr. Dre And The Battle For Apple's Cash

May 12 2014, 8:34am CDT | by

The news that Apple is nearing a $3.2 billion acquisition to buy Beats Electronics is one of the biggest business stories in the nation. The potential deal has received so much attention because it would be Apple’s biggest acquisition ever. It would push rapper and music producer Dr. Dre’s net worth to an estimated $800 million or so. It has already sparked a vigorous debate about Apple’s strategy in the music business and the future of streaming music.

But there is something else going on here. There is a hugely consequential battle underway for Apple’s cash that will produce some massive winners. Apple has an absolutely enormous amount of cash. Its cash horde now stands at some $150 billion. As Apple started to accumulate this unprecedented treasure chest last decade, CEO Steve Jobs stubbornly refused to spend any of it. A unique and extraordinary man, Jobs built what at one point was the world’s biggest company by market value by urging people to “think different.” He consistently baffled observers by resisting calls to spend his company’s money, saying on a conference call in 2010 that “we’d like to continue to keep our powder dry.”

Since Jobs passed away in 2011, the calls for Apple to do something with its cash have grown stronger. As the company’s cash on hand kept growing, it became inevitable that Apple CEO Tim Cook would need to put the money to work one way or another.  The loudest call for Apple’s cash has come from some of the company’s shareholders. They want it. Billionaire hedge fund manager David Einhorn, whose Greenlight Capital hedge fund owns Apple shares, last year publicly lobbied for Apple to return some of its cash to shareholders, saying Apple was behaving like his grandmother and had adopted a “depression-era mentality.” Einhorn put forward a proposal that Apple should issue perpetual preferred shares that he called iPrefs, which would pay dividends to its owners. Einhorn even sued Apple at one point, but eventually dropped the lawsuit after winning a favorable ruling.

Next up, billionaire activist investor Carl Icahn made Apple his biggest single stock holding and started agitating for the company to repurchase a large number of its shares. At one point, Icahn had a dinner with Cook and said he wanted a $150 billion stock buyback. “It’ a no brainer and it makes no sense for this company with their multiple being so low not to do a major buyback,” Icahn said in October. He submitted a non-binding shareholder resolution to push for a $50 billion buyback, but by February 2014 he abandoned his effort. But Icahn, Einhorn and the other investors clamoring for Apple’s cash helped push the company to return capital to shareholders in a serious way. Apple is now in the process of returning $130 billion to shareholders via dividends and buybacks by the end of 2015.

But Apple’s potential deal for Beats has now made it seem possible that people who are not Apple shareholders could be the biggest winners of a Cook spending spree. As Peter Kafka of Re/code noted after the Financial Times first broke the news of the deal talks between Apple and Beats, “if the Beats deal means Apple has changed its perspective, Silicon Valley deal-making may get much more interesting.”

Apple has consistently avoided making big deals in the past, but if the Beats transaction means Cook is ready to go into deal-making mode, the trickle down effect in the tech world could turn into a flood. Facebook recently turned Jan Koum and Brian Acton into billionaires by buying the messaging service they founded, WhatsApp, for $19 billion.  Jim Goetz and his venture capital firm Sequoia were the big financial backers of WhatsApp and their funds will get some $3 billion from the deal, the largest venture capital exit of all time.

It makes sense that Silicon Valley would get excited about Apple and its mountains of cash joining the deal-making fray. Marc Andreessen, co-founder of one of the most powerful venture capital firms in Silicon Valley and a prolific tweeter, took to Twitter after news of the Beats talks broke to point out that Apple produces about $1 billion of cash a week and could generate the cash to pay for the Beats acquisition in three weeks. “Question is not why are they being aggressive in buying Beats; question is why are they so conservative on not buying everything else?” Andreessen tweeted. When I replied to Andreessen that, as a Silicon Valley venture capitalist, he “would not mind if Apple started buying up everything in sight,” Andreessen scolded me to try “engaging on logic instead of ad hominem.” When hedge fund manager John Hempton tweeted that Andreessen’s comments were “said by someone with plenty to sell them,” Andreessen took a friendlier tact. “Sorry, I can’t quite make out what you’re saying, I’m heading into a parking garage,” he replied.

For now, the biggest early winners of the battle for Apple’s cash could very well be Beats co-founders Dr. Dre and Jimmy Iovine, and Bill Conway and David Rubenstein, the billionaire private equity co-founders of the Carlyle Group, the private equity firm known for doing leveraged buyouts of government contractors and industrial companies that uncharacteristically invested $500 million in Beats last year.

In some ways, the man who has the most at stake is Tim Cook. For Cook, the direction where Apple’s cash flows will certainly help define him. One of the most important jobs of most CEOs—perhaps even the most important—is determining how the excess cash that is generated by their companies is spent and allocated. Maybe Apple will invent a killer television set. But just as likely, Cook’s cash decisions will determine his legacy and shape the future of Silicon Valley and the technology sector for a long time to come.

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

NASA spacecraft to reach Mars this weekend
Washington, Sep 18 (IANS) US space agency NASA said Wednesday its Mars Atmosphere and Volatile Evolution (MAVEN) spacecraft will enter orbit around the Red Planet this weekend.
 
 
The Apple Watch Gold Edition Reportedly Costing $4,999
The Apple Watch Gold Edition Reportedly Costing $4,999
An analyst predicts about a very high price of the premium version of the Apple Watch
 
 
The Apple Watch Gold Edition Reportedly Costing $4,999
The Apple Watch Gold Edition Reportedly Costing $4,999
An analyst predicts about a very high price of the premium version of the Apple Watch
 
 
Apple Watch Could Cause More Road Accidents In the UK
Apple Watch Could Cause More Road Accidents In the UK
The IAM believes that the use of Apple Watch would distract the drivers significantly
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Justin Long coped with TV host's antics despite surgery
Los Angeles, Sep 18 (IANS) Actor Justin Long, who underwent hernia surgery last week, cooperated with Andy Cohen's antics on his show. Soon after the surgery, Long appeared on Cohen's late night show "Watch What...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
No truth in Anushka's marriage rumours
Chennai, Sep 18 (IANS) Refuting rumours that southern actress Anushka Shetty is getting hitched after she finishes working on S.S Rajamouli's Telugu magnum opus "Baahubali", her manager said that there was "no truth"...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Australian police raid terror suspects
Sydney, Sep 18 (IANS) Australian police and the nation's spy agency launched raids in homes in Sydney and Brisbane Thursday. More than 600 officers from multiple police departments swooped on homes in the early hours...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Ben Affleck admits to counting cards
Ben Affleck admits he was caught counting cards in Las Vegas in April. The 'Argo' star, who has three children, Violet, eight, Seraphina, five, and two-year-old Samuel, with wife Jennifer Garner, says he has been...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Iggy Azalea is suing her ex-boyfriend
Iggy Azalea is suing her ex-boyfriend, who claims to have a sex tape featuring the star. The Australian rapper has filed a lawsuit against Hefe Wine, accusing him of illegally downloading the entire contents of her...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
George Clooney to toast marriage with tequila
George Clooney plans to toast his upcoming nuptials with his own tequila. The 53-year-old actor's close friend and rumored best man Rande Gerber, who is married to supermodel Cindy Crawford, was spotted loading 100...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Beyonce, Jay Z working on new album?
Los Angeles, Sep 18 (IANS) Singer Beyoncé Knowles and her estranged husband-rapper Jay Z are reportedly teaming up to create a special album together. Karli Henriquez, vice president of Pop Programming at Dash Radio,...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Mendes, Gosling cried after baby's birth
Los Angeles, Sep 18 (IANS) Actors Eva Mendes and Ryan Gosling got so emotional after the birth of their daughter that they burst into tears. The couple, who have been dating since September 2011, reportedly overcame...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
House okay's Obama's plan to train, equip Syrian rebels
Washington, Sep 18 (IANS) The US House of Representatives Wednesday approved President Barack Obama's plan to train and equip Syrian rebels as part of efforts to fight the Islamic State militant group. The chamber...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Pro-Britain, independence supporters put final efforts
Edinburgh, Sep 18 (IANS) Both sides in the Scottish referendum campaign have held rallies Wednesday as they make their final efforts to win over undecided voters, BBC reported. Independence supporters attended a mass...
Read more on Politics Balla