Apple Has Dazzling Sideshow, But Main Event Is Boring

Apr 26 2014, 6:34pm CDT | by

Imagine. Steve Jobs comes onstage, firing up his iPad to project beautiful tables and charts of money. From the stage sofa, he announces Apple’s stock split (“Now the little investor can buy 70 shares instead of only ten”). He then tells about the big dividend money being distributed to shareholders (“We trust you to put it to better use than we can”). Next, he explains the large increase in share buybacks (“We have it in our control to grow our earnings-per-share through share attrition.”) Then, with pride, he announces that this largesse can be done without recalling taxable overseas cash deposits by simply borrowing the money (“Apple Aims for Another Blockbuster Bond Deal”).

A year after it pulled off a then-corporate record $17 billion bond sale, Apple Inc.’s plans to raise a similar sum this year….

Apple expects to sell debt in the U.S. and abroad and use any proceeds to fund the company’s share repurchases and dividends, Luca Maestri, vice president and corporate controller, said on Apple’s earnings call on Wednesday….

Apple said late Wednesday that it added $30 billion to its stock-buyback plan and aims to return more than $130 billion to shareholders by the end of 2015. It also raised its dividend about 8%. Chief Executive Tim Cook said the company expanded the buyback program because management doesn’t believe the full value of the company is reflected in the stock price.

The audience response?

It depends on the attendee’s point of view:

  • Cheers by the Wall Street activist types, as they ready their “Sell” tickets now that AAPL has popped 8+%
  • Polite applause from the long-term investors, still hoping that financial cleverness somehow benefits Apple’s fundamental outlook
  • All quiet on the Apple-nerd front, as they tweet “WTB?” (“Where’s the beef?”) and reconsider their career choices

So, what’s wrong with the actions Cook is taking?

It’s a sideshow that has no meaningful effect on Apple’s future in the big tent of technological innovation. Cook is fiddling while Apple’s competitive prospects are stagnating or worse.

Look at this situation this way: None of the announced actions will affect Apple’s core business one iota. Even a rise in the stock price won’t help because Apple doesn’t use the stock to make any significant acquisitions. Therefore, that price bump is not to be trusted. Here are the problems:

Companies cannot buy long-term investors with financial gimmicks

Yes, there are investors and observers who view dividend increases, share buybacks and stock splits as positive news. However, analysts, portfolio managers and savvy investors are not taken in when those tactics do not reflect underlying company strength and growth. Financial actions taken solely to boost the stock price are viewed as management schemes, not wise strategy. Moreover…

Stock splits are non-events and do not lead to higher prices

Yes, we read about splits being the management-board’s insider-type announcement of good times ahead. However, the basis for that belief is flawed. The split is only confirmation that the preceding stock rise was viewed by the management-board as reason to re-price the stock.

In fact, it can be the absence of a stock split that is important, but only for a company that has stock split policy. Caterpillar’s decision not to split its stock in 2011 is a good example (see “Caterpillar: Important News Coming Soon”). Here’s the graph from that article:

But what about those studies proving that splits invariably lead to higher price gains?

Don’t believe them. The most rigorous studies, done years ago, disproved that notion (and many other investors’ homespun beliefs – like “Sell in May and go away,” etc. etc.). Done properly, here is the picture of excess performance before and after stock split:

Worse are the articles describing today’s studies. Often, authors include an “I know someone who buys on the event and makes a big return” – the same kind of spurious proof found in Internet chain letters.

The bottom line/>/>

Probably the best saying for long-term Apple investors to recall now is, “It’s not your father’s Oldsmobile.” Apple’s shiny new, Wall Street approved, exterior hides the underpowered innovation engine inside. Jobs’ Apple was powered by an “innovation first, last and foremost” strategy.  Cook’s Apple has converted to an alternative fuel:  financial cleverness. (Proof? When Icahn arrived on the scene, Cook said he had a nice meeting with him. Jobs response undoubtedly would have been markedly different.)

Of course, this situation doesn’t mean AAPL will go nowhere. In the stock market, just about anything can happen. But it does prove that long-time Apple shareholders are invested in a different company today than the one they bought originally. The question is whether to move on to other, more promising, growth companies. Not doing so means the investor’s rationale (and investment approach) has changed. With professional investors, such a change is cause for criticism, even dismissal. So, investors need to carefully consider what it means to hang on.

But, what about Apple’s valuation? Isn’t it cheap?

Yes, AAPL is cheap – still. But that’s a weak sign in this market. Even with the recent biotech and tech declines, valuations of companies with good potential growth remain higher – as they should. AAPL’s lower valuation (using forward P/E = 54th of 72 tech companies in the S&P 500) is a measure of lower growth potential, not an indicator of a price explosion about to happen.

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Man with 'disconnected' brain, alive and kicking at 88!
New York, Sep 1 (IANS) This may sound and read unbelievable but there is an elderly man whose brain has no neural fibre connection between his two hemispheres!
 
 
Women at greater stroke risk from resistant hyper-tension
London, Sep 1 (IANS) The condition known as Resistant Hyper-tension increases stroke risk by 35 percent in women and 20 percent in elderly patients, according to new research.
 
 
World's first battery-less pacemaker in the works
London, Sep 1 (IANS) In a revolutionary breakthrough for heart patients, scientists have come up with a way to power a cardiac pacemaker with an alternative energy source - the heart motion.
 
 
New blood test to reliably detect TB in kids
London, Sep 1 (IANS) About one million children per year develop tuberculosis (TB) worldwide, but unfortunately detecting TB in children has been a challenge as the symptoms are often non-specific and similar to those of common paediatric illnesses, including pneumonia and malnutrition.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Double podium for Reddy in Formula Renault
Snetterton (England), Sep 1 (IANS) Young Indian driver Tarun Reddy achieved his best racing weekend with a double podium finish in the UK Formula Renault Championship by finishing second, third and fourth here. The 16...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
IS committing crimes against humanity in Iraq: UN
Geneva, Sep 1 (IANS/EFE) Violence carried out by militants of the Islamic State (IS) Sunni extremist organisation in Iraq, including murders, executions, abduction, sexual violence and torture, amount to crimes against...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Iran vows to free Al-Aqsa mosque from Israel
Tehran, Sep 1 (IANS) Iran's President Hassan Rouhani Monday vowed to liberate the Al-Aqsa mosque in the old city of Jerusalem from the Israeli forces and spare no efforts to help the Palestinian people, state-owned...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
200,000 Indians granted Saudi visas in one month
Riyadh, Sep 1 (IANS) More than 200,000 Indians, mostly domestic helpers and labourers, were granted visas by Saudi authorities in one month, an official said Monday. "Since we resumed bringing in Indian workers at the...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Number of SAARC regional centres to be slashed
Kathmandu, Sep 1 (IANS) SAARC member states have agreed to bring down the number of the association's regional centres from 11 to five in order to end the duplication of work and to reduce expenditure. A meeting of...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Now, 'electronic nose' to detect diarrhoea
London, Sep 1 (IANS) In what could lead to faster diagnosis of diarrhoea and stomach cramps, researchers have developed an "electronic nose" that can sniff the highly infectious bacteria that causes these diseases....
Read more on Business Balla
 
Japan has committed $35-bn investment in India: Modi
Tokyo, Sep 1 (IANS) Prime Minister Narendra Modi Monday signalled a new era of ties with Japan and welcomed the commitment made by his host and Japanese counterpart Shinzo Abe to invest $35 billion in India over the...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Indian in UAE unable to pay bills, hospital says go home
Abu Dhabi, Sep 1 (IANS) An uninsured Indian man has run up more than $160,000 in medical bills after he suffered a brain haemorrhage and spent about six months in an Abu Dhabi hospital, a media report said. The...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Abe wants 'special strategic' ties with India
Tokyo, Sep 1 (IANS) Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe Monday said ties with India should be elevated to a "special strategic partnership". "We have to fundamentally improve our ties in every field to elevate our...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
New blood test to reliably detect TB
London, Sep 1 (IANS) A new blood test has been developed to provide a fast and accurate tool to diagnose tuberculosis in children. About one million children develop tuberculosis (TB) globally each year but detecting...
Read more on Business Balla