Caterpillar Bulldozes Tax Code Like Apple, Google & Facebook, Senators Allege

Apr 1 2014, 7:02pm CDT | by

Caterpillar Bulldozes Tax Code Like Apple, Google & Facebook, Senators Allege
Photo Credit: Forbes Apple

Caterpillar sidestepped $2.4 billion in U.S. taxes over 13 years by shifting profits to Switzerland, claims a report  by the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigation . Senator Carl Levin (D-MI) grilled execs and PricewaterhouseCoopers accountants over Caterpillar’s offshore move of 85% of its parts sales. Most of Caterpillar’s parts business remains in the U.S., including employees and execs, the report says. Only 65 of over 8,000 parts employees are in Switzerland, claims Sen. Levin, noting that “nothing changed in the operations.”

Sen. Levin called it a sweetheart “tax deal pure and simple to shift profits between related parties.” But Caterpillar V.P. Julie Lagacy defended the deal saying it was legit. This echoes others who have appeared before Levin, including Apple CEO Tim Cook. The biggest surprise of the hearing was the Republican pushback defending Caterpillar and noting that the tax code was to blame.

In fact, Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., went so far as to suggest that Caterpillar deserved an award, not an inquisition. Sen. Paul said Caterpillar and its accountants have an obligation to shareholders to minimize their taxes. The hearing was perhaps most uncomfortable for the accountants asked about emails that seemed to poke fun at the fact that they might be retired by the time of an audit.

Nevertheless, there was nothing definitive in the hearing, other than that taxes are terribly complex, and that multinational companies can and do try to move things around to save. Apple’s Tim Cook testified to the same effect, though without the Republican support Caterpillar mustered.

Individuals may scratch their heads at how U.S. multinational companies manage to plop profits offshore. After all, the Swiss banking scandals since 2008 make it clear that for individuals, everything is income worldwide. Multinational companies are different, and even “stateless” income is possible.

Yet Sen. Levin and others would like to see more harmony in the tax code and a tightening of this “stateless” income. Tax havens like Ireland are favored by global giants like Apple, Google, HP, Facebook and Twitter. In May 2013, the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations said Apple avoided $9 billion in U.S. taxes in 2012 alone via offshore units with no tax home. Apple’s CEO Tim Cook testified it was nothing illegal.

Calling it the “holy grail of tax avoidance,” Sen. Levin claimed that Apple saved billions by claiming companies registered in Ireland are not tax resident in any country. Even Facebook flipped more than $700 million to the Cayman Islands as part of a “Double Irish” tax reduction strategy. Google used the Double Irish and the Dutch Sandwich , saving billions in U.S. taxes. No, these aren’t food products.

The Double Irish involves forming a pair of Irish companies to transform payments on intellectual property into tax-deductible royalty payments. Google and Microsoft cut their overseas tax rates to single digits with Dublin-registered subsidiaries designated as tax resident in Bermuda. Google and Apple have Irish-registered and tax resident subsidiaries that make sales to customers.

Global companies like Apple, Starbucks and Hewlett-Packard put income in foreign pockets in ways the IRS doesn’t like. And the IRS isn’t alone in its criticism. The G20 countries and the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD ) call it tax manipulation. The OECD, which advises the G20 on tax and economic policy, says existing national tax enforcement regimes just don’t work.

The OECD plan claims that companies like Apple and Google avoid billions in taxes. The G20 is made up of 19 leading world economies plus the European Union. It too has voiced support for a fundamental reassessment of the rules on taxing multinationals. And in a sense, the Republicans defending Caterpillar are right that the U.S. tax code seems to encourage all this behavior.

Some companies say they would like nothing better than repatriating profits to the U.S. if they could only do it in a way that won’t be taxed. The amounts at stake are staggering. U.S. companies are said to have more than $1.5 trillion offshore. Most claim that they must keep the money there to avoid the taxes they would face by bringing it back to the U.S.

“We must address the persistent issue of ‘stateless income,’ which undermines confidence in our tax system at all levels,” U.S. Treasury Secretary Jack Lew has said. Sadly, retooling the law, even if there were agreement in Congress, will take time. Meanwhile, despite the hearings and theatrics, little seems likely to change.

You can reach me at Wood@WoodLLP.com . This discussion is not intended as legal advice, and cannot be relied upon for any purpose without the services of a qualified professional.

Source: Forbes Apple

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

5 awesome paid iPhone and iPad apps that are free for a limited time
5 awesome paid iPhone and iPad apps that are free for a limited time
Did you miss out on any of the awesome paid iPhone and iPad apps we’ve shared with you over the past few days that have gone on sale for free for a limited time? Don’t worry… we’ve got five more for you today....
 
 
Nvidia Shield Tablet: Mobile Gaming Strategy Gains Clarity
Nvidia Shield Tablet: Mobile Gaming Strategy Gains Clarity
Nvidia announced today two new members of the SHIELD family, the SHIELD tablet and the SHIELD controller for gaming. This comes on the heels of the Nvidia SHIELD portable released a year ago.  I think the SHIELD tablet...
 
 
Will Investors Get Excited If Apple Only Beats EPS By A Dime?
Will Investors Get Excited If Apple Only Beats EPS By A Dime?
One of the consequences of Apple doing a 7 for 1 stock split is that it will make any EPS beat look materially smaller than before the split. While Tim Cook has provided guidance that is more in-line with what the...
 
 
Apple’s iPhone 6 launch will be even bigger than anyone imagined
Apple’s iPhone 6 launch will be even bigger than anyone imagined
Apple has told suppliers to make between 70 million and 80 million combined 4.7-inch iPhone 6 and 5.5-inch iPhone 6 units by December 30, The Wall Street Journal has learned from sources familiar with the matter, in...
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

5 awesome paid iPhone and iPad apps that are free for a limited time
Did you miss out on any of the awesome paid iPhone and iPad apps we’ve shared with you over the past few days that have gone on sale for free for a limited time? Don’t worry… we’ve got five more for you today....
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Nvidia Shield Tablet: Mobile Gaming Strategy Gains Clarity
Nvidia announced today two new members of the SHIELD family, the SHIELD tablet and the SHIELD controller for gaming. This comes on the heels of the Nvidia SHIELD portable released a year ago.  I think the SHIELD tablet...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Joko Widodo wins Indonesian presidential election
Jakarta, July 22 (IANS) Governor of Indonesia's capital city Jakarta Joko Widodo was Tuesday declared elected Indonesia's new president after the General Election Commission (KPU) settled the vote tally. Making the...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Will Investors Get Excited If Apple Only Beats EPS By A Dime?
One of the consequences of Apple doing a 7 for 1 stock split is that it will make any EPS beat look materially smaller than before the split. While Tim Cook has provided guidance that is more in-line with what the...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Naomi Watts for Demolition?
Naomi Watts in talks to star in 'Demolition'. 'The Impossible' actress is in negotiations to appear alongside Jake Gyllenhaal in the upcoming drama, which is to be directed by 'Dallas Buyers Club' filmmaker Jean-Marc...
Read more on Movie Balla
 
Bradley Cooper had never met Vin Diesel
Bradley Cooper had never met his 'Guardians of the Galaxy' co-star until they appeared together on a talk show to promote the finished film. The 39-year-old actor provides the voice for Rocket the racoon in the upcoming...
Read more on Movie Balla
 
Scandal-hit Mexico shelter centre of physical abuse
Mexico City, July 22 (IANS/EFE) More than 150 abuse complaints have been filed against the La Gran Familia shelter in the western Mexican state of Michoacan, where 500 children who lived in squalid conditions were...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Lovato takes help from Pinterest for hair looks
Los Angeles, July 22 (IANS) Pop star Demi Lovato says she takes hair style inspiration from Pinterest, a visual discovery tool. The 21-year-old, who currently sports lavender and silver ombré-coloured tresses, gets...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Gaza toll 609 as Israeli offensive rages on
Gaza/Jerusalem, July 22 (IANS) The relentless Israeli military campaign dubbed Operation Protective Edge targeting the Gaza Strip, which has lasted for more than two weeks, has killed over 600 Palestinians and wounded...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
China's rotten meat scandal spreads to Japan (Roundup)
Beijing/Tokyo, July 22 (IANS) A rotten meat scandal which led several fast food chains to withdraw some of their most popular dishes in China this week spread to Japan Tuesday, as McDonald's announced it had stopped...
Read more on Politics Balla