Apple Gives The Schoolyard Bully A Bloody Nose, But Did It Win The Fight With Icahn?

Feb 11 2014, 9:30am CST | by

Apple Gives The Schoolyard Bully A Bloody Nose, But Did It Win The Fight With Icahn?

Tim Cook may not look like a fighter, but compared to Carl Icahn, he’s Muhammad Ali. Using Ali’s famous rope-a-dope strategy, Cook let Icahn punch himself out over the span of several months. As a result, Icahn — who originally demanded Apple repurchase an additional $150 billion worth of its stock beyond the $60 billion it had already committed to — has channeled another famous boxer, Roberto Duran, and basically declared no más“. After backing his request down to just $50 billion more, Icahn is now pretending Apple is doing that (it isn’t) and saying nice things about the company and its chief executive. So Cook certainly wins this clash of the titans, basically by having dinner with Icahn, taking a phone call and otherwise blowing him off. But did he solve any of Apple’s capital allocation problems? Not really. Let’s take a look at why and what Apple might do about it.

$100 billion ‘returned to shareholders’

When Apple announced it was returning $100 billion to shareholders over 3 years in the form of dividends and $60 billion in share repurchases, I explained why that wouldn’t dent Apple’s cash balance when all was said and done. In the past 5 quarters, Apple spent $41 billion on those activities (not including the recent $14 billion in share buybacks that occurred after the most recent quarter ended). During that time, the cash on its balance sheet actually grew to $158 billion from $147 billion. Now, in fairness, the recent repurchase will bring that number back in line with where it was when Apple expanded the buyback to record levels. It also took on $17 billion in debt. But the company made $37 billion last year and started fiscal 2014 with $13 billion more. The fact is, if you assume zero earnings growth, Apple will net $60 billion more in the balance of the next 2 fiscal years, spend $20 billion on dividends, $20 billion on share buybacks and could reserve $20 billion for retiring debt. After all that math, it winds up back where it started.

And that spot is at close to $150 billion in cash. Even if Cook does find a company worth $10-20 billion to buyas he said recently he might do, Apple would still be holding more cash that any company and more than any possible scenario could reasonably justify. So if not Icahn’s plan for a massive expansion of the buyback, what then? There are a number of interesting strategic options (one this space has looked at before, which it will revisit again in the very near future), but today’s installment is limited to financial discussions.

A smaller fixed buyback program

Though I personally don’t believe in buybacks and academic research tends to back up the belief they are of dubious merit, here are some numbers to chew on. If Apple committed to buy back $10 billion worth of stock each year beyond the current commitment, that would retire 18 million additional shares at a price of $550 per share. (The assumption here is the stock will be worth a bit more, at least, by 2015 when this program would begin). Apple currently has under 900 million shares outstanding, so everyone who didn’t sell would effectively own 2% more of Apple in the first year of this program.

The reduction in shares outstanding saves Apple $220 million in dividend payments using the current dividend. which is true not just in the first year, but every year going forward. Taking the present value of those dividends produces a value of about $3.5 billion using a 6% discount rate. Given Apple’s oddly conservative cash management for the past several years — it mostly keeps its money in short term T-bills earning less than 1% — you might be able to make a case for a lower discount rate and a higher number, but treating the dividends as perpetual is also a bit fraught, so the $3.5 billion seems fair. In this event, Apple is basically taking $10 billion and turning it into $3.5 billion, but also making every shareholder 2% richer. (Should the company decide to finance these repurchases with short-term bonds, it would likely borrow $200 million or so come 2015 and get back $50 million in tax savings. The stock market might value Apple higher with the additional debt due to the perverse nature of such things, but it’s hard to project that.)

Bigger dividends

Apple currently pays out $12.20 per share annually, or a bit over 2% against the share price. The company could do all sorts of things like target a 3% dividend, which would raise the payment to $16 or so. That would cost remarkably little, say $3 billion annually depending on the precise numbers. It could also announce a formula for dividend payments as a function of income. Right now, dividends are approximately 27% of earnings. The company could raise the target to 35% or 40%. By using a formula, the board would then be in a position to signal the market about business prospects by changing the formula from time to time. If the percentage was raised, it would indicate Apple believed even more cash was coming in. If lowered, it would be a way of saying Apple was tightening its belt for tougher times.

The judge’s scorecard

The astute reader has probably caught on to a flaw in the above. Apple still doesn’t end up spending any of its money unless it picks a larger buyback number or an even more aggressive dividend formula. Because some investors don’t like dividends — those not holding shares in tax-advantaged accounts and those in the highest brackets, for instance — there is probably a limit on how high the dividend ought to be. But even still, a 5% yield on the common stock would not be sufficient to dent the cash hoard. Nor would such a dividend combined with a $10 billion annual buyback.

This leaves Apple having beaten back Icahn’s agitating much as it had with David Einhorn, another hedge-funder a year ago. But it leaves the company no closer to addressing the $150 billion elephant in the room. And the fact remains that the pile of cash is dragging on the company’s stock. Investors look at it and wonder if it reflects a company out of ideas on what to do with the money or one desperately afraid of a future where it will be much less profitable than it is today. The point isn’t whether those concerns are entirely well-founded, the point is they’re real. Apple has now been sitting on more than $100 billion since early in 2012. If it wants to be treated better on Wall Street — and actions like the capital return program certainly are evidence that it does — it will need to find a way to start moving back toward that number.

Follow me on Twitter and on Facebook. Find the rest of my Forbes posts here.

Source: Forbes Apple

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Apple’s New SIM Card Is Great For Travelers
Apple’s New SIM Card Is Great For Travelers
The latest iPad comes with SIM cards perfect for people on the go
 
 
Tim Cook Met With Chinese Officials On Privacy
Tim Cook Met With Chinese Officials On Privacy
The Chinese government has taken an interest in Apple’s security and privacy
 
 
Why Is Apple Pay The Most Secure Option Available?
Why Is Apple Pay The Most Secure Option Available?
Is Apple Pay really worth the hype?
 
 
Apple Planning to Open 25 New Stores in China within Two Years
Apple Planning to Open 25 New Stores in China within Two Years
Tim Cook reveals that Apple is thinking to build 25 additional stores in the massive Chinese market
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Second MERS case reported in Qatar
Doha, Oct 23 (IANS) A 43-year-old man in Qatar has tested positive for Middle East Respiratory Syndrome (MERS) in the second confirmed case of the deadly virus in 10 days, media reported Thursday. The patient had...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Two people die in Pakistan bomb blast
Islamabad, Oct 23 (IANS) At least two people were killed and 12 others injured in an explosion that took place in Pakistan's Balochistan province Thursday, media reported. The bomb was planted on a motorcycle, Dawn...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Trott extends contract with Warwickshire till 2017
London, Oct 23 (IANS) England batsman Jonathan Trott, whose mental issues led to his abrupt departure from last winter's Ashes tour, has confirmed his successful comeback to competitive cricket by signing a new three-...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Srikanth, Kashyap big movers in BWF rankings
Kuala Lumpur, Oct 23 (IANS) Indian men shuttlers Kidambi Srikanth and Parupalli Kashyap jumped seven places each in the latest Badminton World Federation (BWF) rankings released Thursday while Olympic bronze medallist...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Alvin Stardust dead
London, Oct 23 (IANS) English singer Alvin Stardust died after a short illness. He was 72. Stardust's manager confirmed the news about his demise Thursday, reports mirror.co.uk. He was recently diagnosed with...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Indian man reunited with family after 40 years
Dubai, Oct 23 (IANS) An Indian man, who had disappeared from his hometown in Kerala nearly 40 years ago, has been found by his family at a hospital in Dubai in the UAE, a newspaper report said. Now in his 60s, Abdulla...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Srikanth, Kashyap, Saina rise in world rankings
Kala Lumpur, Oct 23 (IANS) Indian men shuttlers Kidambi Srikanth and Parupalli Kashyap jumped seven places each in the latest released Badminton World Federation (BWF) rankings Thursday while Olympic bronze medallist...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Flintoff signs for Big Bash side Brisbane Heat
Brisbane, Oct 23 (IANS) Former England captain and all-rounder Andrew Flintoff, who retired from international cricket in 2009, Wednesday confirmed that he will play for Brisbane Heat in the Big Bash League (BBL) this...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
OPEC daily basket price falls again
Vienna, Oct 23 (IANS/WAM) The basket of 12 crude oils of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) closed at $81.94 a barrel Wednesday compared to $82.09 Tuesday, the OPEC Secretariat said. The new OPEC...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Lopez to sign multi-million dollar deal?
Los Angeles, Oct 23 (IANS) Singer-actress Jennifer Lopez is reportedly in the final stages of securing a multi-million dollar deal to perform in Las Vegas. The 45-year-old is being offered $350,000 per show at The...
Read more on Celebrity Balla