Apple Puts Carl Icahn's $150 Billion Buyback Proposal To Shareholders

Dec 28 2013, 12:16pm CST | by

As we know Carl Icahn has been urging Apple’s management and Tim Cook to increase the share buyback and dividend distributions that the company makes. There’s a certain amount of sense to the proposal as the company does have some $140 billion or so in cash and near cash on its balance sheet. It’s also something being resisted by the management for what also seem like good reasons.

Apple has just filed with the SEC to show that Icahn’s proposal will be one for shareholders to vote upon at the annual general meeting next month:

A shareholder proposal by Carl Icahn of a non-binding advisory resolution that the Company commit to completing not less than $50 billion of share repurchases during its 2014 fiscal year (and increase the authorization under its capital return program accordingly) (Proposal No. 10)

Apple have also pointed out how they advise shareholders to vote on this matter:

“AGAINST” the shareholder proposal by Carl Icahn of a non-binding advisory resolution that the Company commit to completing not less than $50 billion of share repurchases during its 2014 fiscal year (and increase the authorization under its capital return program accordingly) (Proposal No. 10)

Just to avoid confusion: Icahn’s proposal is usually referred to as a “$150 billion” one, but the vote will be on only $50 billion. This is because Icahn’s proposal is in addition to Apple’s already signed off on $100 billion distribution via dividends and buybacks over the next couple of years. So we’re referring to Icahn’s idea as the total amount, not the additional amount of it.

And the specific language to be voted on is:

The Company has been advised that High River Limited Partnership (“High River”), 767 Fifth Avenue, 46th Floor, New York, New York, 10153, a record holder of 1,000 shares of the Company’s common stock, intends to submit the following proposal at the Annual Meeting on behalf of itself and Icahn Partners LP, Icahn Partners Master Fund LP, Icahn Partners Master Fund II LP, Icahn Partners Master Fund III LP, and other beneficial owners, including Mr. Carl Icahn:

“RESOLVED, that the shareholders hereby approve, on an advisory basis, High River’s proposal that Apple commit to completing not less than $50 billion of share repurchases during Apple’s fiscal year ending September 27, 2014 (and increase the amount authorized for share repurchases under its Capital Return Program accordingly).

The basic reason to be in favour of this is that Apple does indeed have mountains of cash at its disposal and the shareholders would probably like to get their hands on some of it. It does, after all, belong to them. And it’s most certainly true that there are managements out there that you would prefer did not have mountains of cash at their disposal because the worry is that they’ll only go and waste it. This is what led to Vodafone returning much of the Verizon money to shareholders directly, it’s also something that has been vaguely worried about over at Yahoo. It’s all too easy to squander such cash piles with a value destroying takeover just to give one example.

On the other hand there are also argument against a larger payback to shareholders. One is that while Apple does have that pile it’s not all available to be returned to shareholders. A lot of it is actually offshore and cannot be used in a buyback or dividend distribution without paying US corporate income tax on it. Indeed, Apple is already borrowing to pay the current distribution. Spending down a cash pile is one thing, gearing up to finance one something of a different question.

It’s also true that we don’t see any evidence of the Apple management thinking about launching one of those value destroying takeovers. So it’s not as if having that cash available is actually harmful. Indeed, what we actually see them doing with the awesome financial firepower at their disposal seems to be in line with the long term development of the business. For example, they obviously wanted to use more sapphire in the iPhone (and possibly iPad) but they didn’t go off and try to buy the technology. Nor did they try to develop it from scratch. Rather, they financed, through pre-purchase of the production, a new factory with the next generation of production technology. This is a field I know reasonably well (I work with a sapphire producer on an entirely different product) and that does indeed look like an eminently sensible use of the resources they have. They’ll end up with better and cheaper sapphire as a result, their loss will be pretty much only the interest they’ll lose on the cash. A small interest loss and no equity risk: sounds good to me. I can see them doing this in other fields: not vertical integration so much as financing the development of the components needed to make iKit even better. I doubt they’ll finance a new fab for the processing chips but there’s no doubt that they could.

Obviously, the vote is for Apple shareholders to decide upon and I’m not one of those. Nor am I trying to give advice one way or the other. I am only laying out the issues as I see them.

Source: Forbes Apple

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Judge Rejects Apple’s Request to Dismiss States’ E-book Antitrust Cases
Judge Rejects Apple’s Request to Dismiss States’ E-book Antitrust Cases
The Judge dismisses Apple’s appeal regarding the e-book antitrust case, which might force the company to pay $840 million in damages
 
 
Apple's June Quarter Guidance Could Be Ugly
Apple is scheduled to release its March quarter results on Wednesday, April 23, and if it maintains its usual practice will provide guidance for the next quarter in its press release. After running my Apple model for...
 
 
In Their Own Words: Cylance Founder And CEO Stuart McClure
In Their Own Words: Cylance Founder And CEO Stuart McClure
If you are familiar with the world of computer and network security, there is a very good chance you are familiar with Stuart McClure. At the very least, the name probably rings a bell. I have actually known Stuart for...
 
 
Apple Launches the New 8GB iPhone 5C in Six Countries
Apple Launches the New 8GB iPhone 5C in Six Countries
Apple is trying to increase the sale of 8GB iPhone 5C by launching it in 6 new countries
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Yahoo Earnings: Costs Drag Profitability Even As Revenue Grows
Yahoo! reported its first quarter earnings Tuesday, April 15. The company posted a 1% year-on-year growth in net revenues (excluding Traffic Acquisition Cost or TAC) to $1.087 billion. However, the non-GAAP operating...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Burger King Worldwide New Coverage: $29 Trefis Price Estimate
Burger King Worldwide is a fast food restaurant chain, which operates in the quick service restaurant category. Founded in 1954, it has over 13,600 restaurants across 97 countries. In 2010, Burger King was acquired by...
Read more on Business Balla
 
A Market Shakedown
As a student of the markets, I have learned to abide by a principle of economist Herb Stein which states, “If something cannot go on forever, it will stop.”  The recent bout of market volatility was propelled by a...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Top YTD Industry Groups
For the second day in a row, stocks were able to overcome intra-day selling to close with nice gains. The market internals were positive but not as strong as they were on Monday. The short-term A/D indicators, like the...
Read more on Business Balla
 
GARY: Growth At The Right Yield™ - A New Approach to Dividend Stocks
Tell-tale Investment Advisors has developed a unique and trademarked style of equity investing which they call “GARY” Investing. GARY stands for Growth At the Right Yield™. We have worked with Tell-tale to reduce their...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Relative Strength Alert For Himax Technologies
The DividendRank formula at Dividend Channel ranks a coverage universe of thousands of dividend stocks, according to a proprietary formula designed to identify those stocks that combine two important characteristics —...
Read more on Business Balla
 
ASML Holding is Now Oversold (ASML)
Legendary investor Warren Buffett advises to be fearful when others are greedy, and be greedy when others are fearful. One way we can try to measure the level of fear in a given stock is through a technical analysis...
Read more on Business Balla
 
AUY Stock Crowded With Sellers
In trading on Wednesday, shares of Yamana Gold, Inc. (NYSE: AUY) entered into oversold territory, changing hands as low as $8.02 per share. We define oversold territory using the Relative Strength Index, or RSI, which...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Welcome To The Show: The Demise Of The Public Market And Rise Of Reality
It’s the ultimate question on investor’s minds. Is this the beginning of the long anticipated correction? You will hear the long list of market cheerleaders proclaim the sacred strategy of buy and hold as the way to  ...
Read more on Business Balla
 
What Pre-Retirees Should Be Asking About Taxes
By Holly Kylen, Next Avenue Contributor Now that April 15 has come and gone, many Americans are beginning to evaluate their finances and start planning for the coming year. For those retiring in the next five to 10...
Read more on Business Balla
 
 
Auto Balla Sexy Balla Sport Balla TV Balla Politics Balla Movie Balla Apple Balla Business Balla Ad Balla Celebrity Balla